Canadian officials knew of Afghan torture claims: Documents

This article appeared at :

By Jeff Davis and Jordan Press, Postmedia News

June 23, 2011 – Thousands of pages of newly released documents about Afghan detainees show  diplomats were aware of widespread abuse, such as electrocutions, whippings and  sleep deprivation, in Afghan prisons where Canada’s detainees were held.

The documents appear to support the government’s assertion that Canadians did  not knowingly transfer detainees who were tortured.

However, the 362 heavily censored documents released Wednesday describe  private torture chambers, squalid prisons, rumours of summary executions and  officials losing track of Canada’s detainees.

The political fallout continued Thursday, a day after the government released  more than 4,000 pages of documents.

Opposition parties are demanding a public inquiry, saying the document dump  had not answered key questions.

NDP defence critic Jack Harris chided the government for spending $12 million — the cost of preparing the documents for release — “to suppress the truth.”

“This is clear evidence they knew something was up,” Harris told Postmedia  News Thursday.

Foreign Affairs Minister John Baird said the yearlong process culminated with  an “unprecedented amount of information” being put before politicians and the  public.

“Canadians have got a clear picture that our men and women in uniform fully  accepted all of our international obligations and have done a heck of a good job  representing this country,” Baird said.

The documents show Canadian diplomats heard allegations of abuse and  mistreatment on a regular basis in 2006 and 2007, and were aware of the Afghan  National Directorate of Security’s pattern of torture.

Diplomats relayed allegations of torture to senior cabinet ministers in  Ottawa, who raised the issue with Afghan authorities. In one document listing  “actions on the detainees issue” for 2007, a redacted and summarized portion  noted Prime Minister Stephen Harper raised concerns with Afghan President Hamid  Karzai.

Although the exact date of the meeting is not filed, Harper made a surprise  visit to Afghanistan on May 22, 2007 and met that day with Karzai. That same  day, the two held a joint news conference where Karzai publicly denied any cases  of detainee abuse.

An account at the time by the Globe and Mail cited 30 cases of prisoners  being abused in Afghan jails.

“We do not have any such case of torture,” Karzai told reporters at the news  conference. “So I can tell you . . . that story was not true, as much as it  caused news and controversy in Canada.”

During a June 2007 visit to an NDS facility in Kabul, Canadian-transferred  detainees told diplomats their bodies and feet had been beaten with cables. One  detainee claimed he had been given electric shocks, while another said he had  been forced to stand for two days.

Detainees also relayed claims from other prisoners that inmates at the NDS  Kandahar facility had their fingers cut and burned with lighters.

In a case that caused Canada to suspend transfers of detainees, one of  Canada’s detainees brought a Canadian official to a room where he was  interrogated, showed the official a four-inch bruise on his back, and pointed  out the “large piece of braided electrical wire” and rubber hose used to beat  him.

The documents also show Canadian officials, in those early days in Kandahar,  had problems tracking detainees they had transferred.

In June 2007, Canadian officials visited an NDS facility to check on 12  detainees transferred by Canadians. They were surprised to learn that 10 had  been released without their knowledge.

Afghan officials criticized Canada for detaining apparently innocent Afghans,  and sending them to detention facilities.

In an April 2007 meeting with NDS chief Amrullah Saleh, Canadian officials  asked how many of the fewer than 150 detainees transferred by Canada’s regular  forces were in fact Taliban, and not innocent local farmers. In response, Saleh  said “he simply did not know.”

“Most of those detained by Canadian Forces, he guessed, would subsequently  have been released,” the report reads.

Transfers of Canada’s detainees to Afghan authorities restarted after the two  nations reached a “Supplementary Agreement,” which granted Canada additional  rights of oversight and visitation.

Canadian officials frequently visited prisons unannounced to interview  detainees. In some cases, Canadian officials were not allowed to meet with  detainees despite the transfer agreement stating they had full access to  detainees.

Numerous minor instances of abuse, such as yelling and slapping, continued to  occur after this new agreement was reached and concerns were raised with Afghan  officials after each incident, federal officials said this week.

During a November 2007 visit to Sarposa prison, one detainee told Canadian  officials that “detainees captured by ISAF forces were treated well but those  captured by Afghans (sic) authorities are often subjected to ill-treatment.”

When journalists reported allegations of abuse, the documents show diplomats  attempted to verify the stories were true. In one case, the documents said  allegations of abuse were “misconstrued” in a newspaper article. In another  case, diplomats determined an anonymous detainee interviewed for a story made  similar claims to Canadians officials. However, verifying the abuse was  impossible “without a name from the journalist.”

Included in the documents are memos authored by diplomat Richard Colvin, who  raised concerns over torture to his superiors.

Colvin’s secret reports from April 2007, sent to Ottawa’s highest-ranking  foreign affairs and security intelligence officials, detailed a meeting held  with Karzai’s chief of staff Omar Daoudzai.

“Awareness of detainee mistreatment was discussed,” Colvin wrote. “Such  practices would constitute a violation of Afghanistan’s international  obligations, as well as Afghan domestic law.”

After visiting Sarposa Prison, Colvin reported he was concerned by the  treatment of detainees handed over by Canada.

“Concern expressed about the situation in Kandahar is not the prison itself  but overall treatment of detainees, including those transferred to Afghan  custody by Canadian forces.”

Colvin described the prison’s general shortcomings, such as guards taking  bribes, children of detainees being kept with the general prison population,  insufficient water and sanitation and lack of prayer facilities.

The name of Asadullah Khalid, governor of Kandahar from 2005 to 2008, also  appears in the documents in relation to claims he personally tortured people in  his prison.

“It has been reported by multiple sources that the governor maintains a  private detention facility,” the documents read. “It has been reported that  Khalid had admitted to keeping detainees there.”

Stories of alleged detainee abuse made their way home to Canada outside of  official channels.

A Military Police academy instructor shared anecdotes of abuse in a lecture  to trainees. He told his class a story he heard second-hand of Afghan National  Army troops dragging a detainee to a grisly death behind a pickup truck.

An investigation was conducted into the incident, which determined the story  to be hearsay.


Read more:


Leave a comment

Filed under afghanistan, Canadian Politics, Community Rights, Human Rights, International Politics, Political Accountability, Security Issues

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s